Fansly vs OnlyFans -- What Should Creators Choose in 2025?
Decide where to invest your time by comparing pricing, payout cadence, discovery tools, and compliance policies side by side. The Soss team analysed both ecosystems using live catalog data and creator interviews.
Verdict at a glance
Highlights before you dive deeper into the feature breakdown.
- Fansly wins for personalisation, tag based discovery, and lower chargeback exposure thanks to rolling holds.
- OnlyFans still offers the deepest subscriber base and more proven third party tooling for automation.
- Pricing power is comparable, but Fansly's token events and tiered trials boost introductory conversions.
- Moderation response times are faster on Fansly; OnlyFans has broader mainstream recognition for sponsorships.
Feature comparison
Every line item reflects the latest publicly available product updates as of January 2025.
| Feature | Fansly | OnlyFans | Takeaway |
|---|---|---|---|
| Platform fees | 20% (plus processor) | 20% (plus processor) | Fee parity. Evaluate based on discovery tools and upsell formats rather than raw revenue share. |
| Payout timing | Daily payouts after 7 day rolling hold, $20 minimum | Weekly payouts, manual withdrawal, $20 minimum | Fansly's automatic cadence helps cash flow; OnlyFans requires manual requests but offers same minimum. |
| Discovery & growth | For You feed, tag browsing, collab shoutouts, API integrations | Limited internal discovery, reliant on external marketing | Fansly surfaces creators natively. OnlyFans still depends on Twitter, Reddit, or paid promos. |
| Content formats | Subscriptions, PPV, token streams, tiered trials, channel chats | Subscriptions, PPV, paid messages, livestreams (beta) | Fansly provides more granular trials and community chat features out of the box. |
| Moderation & compliance | Manual dispute review, faster support, transparent policy updates | Large compliance team, stricter banking influence, slower ticket cycles | Both require full paperwork. Fansly is nimbler; OnlyFans benefits from established banking agreements. |
| Third party ecosystem | Growing API access, Soss integrations, limited automations | Extensive automations, CRM plugs, analytics dashboards | Automation heavy agencies still lean on OnlyFans, though Fansly's API roadmap is accelerating. |
Who should pick which platform?
Match scenarios to the platform that makes growth easiest today.
New creators testing pricing
Start on Fansly to leverage trials and discovery, then mirror winners on OnlyFans once you understand demand.
Fansly's tag based feed can seed your first audience without purchasing promo packs. Use Soss to watch engagement, then copy high performing bundles to OnlyFans for additional reach.
Established OnlyFans earners
Mirror core content on Fansly to diversify risk, but keep exclusive drops or flagship PPVs on OnlyFans where automations are mature.
Schedule mirrored uploads through Soss or your agency CRM. Offer Fansly channel chats or token events as unique perks so fans feel rewarded for following you to a second home.
Agencies & studios
Operate both. OnlyFans supports your automation stack, while Fansly adds safer chargeback policies and API access for custom tooling.
Segment fans by platform using UTM links. Run short, high energy campaigns on Fansly when you need algorithm boosts and keep long form fan nurturing inside OnlyFans DM workflows.
Creators needing PG-13 funnels
Pair Fansly or OnlyFans with Fanhouse/Patreon. Use Soss to direct SFW fans into adult upsells when they opt in to age verification.
Build layered funnels: top-of-funnel Fanhouse for brand deals, Fansly for adult discovery, and OnlyFans for collectors who want premium PPVs.
Migration & multihoming tips
Prep your audience, automate workflows, and keep compliance tight while expanding to a second platform.
- Export subscriber lists (where terms allow) and tag high spenders so you can invite them first to the new platform.
- Clone welcome flows: recreate subscription tiers, automations, and pinned posts so fans recognise the experience.
- Announce migration timelines on social media and inside DMs with clear incentives and safety messaging.
- Use Soss analytics to compare churn, ARPPU, and traffic sources side by side after launch.
- Keep support documentation handy--Fansly and OnlyFans each require identity refreshes when banking details change.
FAQ
Answers to common questions before you restructure your subscription stack.
Which platform charges lower fees?
Both Fansly and OnlyFans keep 20% of subscription and PPV revenue before processor fees. Evaluate platform perks--Fansly's trials and discovery or OnlyFans' automation network--when setting prices.
Where is discoverability better?
Fansly features algorithmic feeds, trending tags, and collab shoutouts, so new creators can be surfaced quickly. OnlyFans still relies mostly on external marketing or paid promo bundles.
Is multihoming allowed?
Yes. Both platforms permit cross posting as long as you honour exclusivity clauses for specific campaigns. Sync your calendars and watermark assets to prevent piracy when publishing in multiple places.
How do payouts compare?
Fansly runs daily payouts after a 7 day rolling hold. OnlyFans processes withdrawals weekly once you request them. Both support mainstream payment partners with similar minimum thresholds.
Continue research with Soss
Explore live rankings, discounts, and platform specific guides for both ecosystems.